write an argumentative essay based on the mckay summary using one outside resource to support your claim
pick a side of and have a counter claim
Based on the summary of the text “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna MacKay, here’s an outline for an argumentative essay:
I. Introduction
A. Brief summary of MacKay’s argument for legalizing and regulating organ sales
B. Importance of addressing the organ shortage crisis
C. Thesis statement: Legalizing and regulating organ sales offers a pragmatic solution to save lives and mitigate the suffering of individuals in need of transplants.
II. Addressing the moral objections
A. Moral concerns about exploitation and coercion of vulnerable individuals
1. Discussion of ethical considerations surrounding organ sales
2. Counterargument: Regulation can mitigate exploitation by ensuring informed consent and fair compensation
B. The efficacy of the current ban on organ sales
1. Examination of the limitations and unintended consequences of the ban
2. Counterargument: Legalization and regulation offer a more effective approach to prevent illegal transplantation and protect the interests of donors and recipients
III. Ensuring safety and equity through regulation
A. Importance of safety in organ transplantation
1. Discussion of risks associated with illegal organ trade
2. Counterargument: Regulation can improve safety standards for both donors and recipients
B. Fair compensation for donors
1. Exploration of ethical considerations regarding financial incentives for organ donation
2. Counterargument: Regulation can ensure fair compensation while safeguarding against exploitation and coercion
C. Addressing disparities in access to transplantation
1. Examination of how regulation can promote equity in organ allocation
2. Counterargument: Legalization can expand access to transplantation for marginalized populations
IV. Potential benefits of legalizing organ sales
A. Saving lives and improving health outcomes
1. Discussion of the life-saving potential of increased organ availability
2. Counterargument: Legalization can alleviate suffering and improve quality of life for individuals with end-stage organ failure
B. Economic and social impact
1. Exploration of how legalizing organ sales can alleviate poverty and reduce healthcare costs
2. Counterargument: Regulation can mitigate negative social consequences and ensure that economic benefits are distributed equitably
V. Conclusion
A. Restate the importance of reevaluating moral stances on organ sales in light of the life-and-death implications
B. Recap the potential benefits of legalizing and regulating organ sales
C. Call to action for policymakers to consider the pragmatic approach of legalizing organ sales to save lives and alleviate suffering.
