Purpose:
Select one of the thematic areas that we have touched on this semester (see the list below) and
write a paper that compares at least three sources we have examined this semester to make an
argument about how the theme plays a significant role in the human condition – both historically
and in the present. Select at least one work from the first part of the course (covered on test 1),
one work from the middle of the course (covered on test 2), and one work from the latter part of
the course (since test 2). These works should represent DIFFERENT cultural contexts (i.e. come
from different geographical areas). You should then compare what each work says about the
thematic topic, identify similarities and differences, AND analyze the importance of those
regarding social/cultural significance of the theme.
Thematic ideas:
1) roles of men and women in society
2) government and civilization’s impact on society
3) relationship between mankind and God/the divine
4) the role of nature versus civilization
5) honor and duty
6) Chivalry and knighthood
7) Other thematic areas (only with the instructor’s prior approval)
Scope:
You MUST do ALL of the following:
1) Select only one (1) thematic idea to focus on
2) Compare the three works you select (only use 3) and identify similarities and differences.
3) Use select quoted material from the works of literature to illustrate/support you
comparison. (No more than about 15-20% of the paper should come from the sources.)
4) Analyze the similarities and differences (including explanation of your ideas) to point out
why the differences are important (i.e. WHY are there differences) AND what is
IMPORTANT about the similarities. Remember that you should be explaining YOUR
ideas, not just presenting someone else’s ideas.
