Assignment Question

The Milagro Beanfield War – Prof. Jeffrey Widener (updated January 25, 2021) Why the movie and not the book? The Milagro Beanfield War same title) written by John Nichols in the 1970s. Its setting is in the “enchanting” milieu of northern New Mexico. The film (and book) portrays a very real struggle that small Hispano villages/communities still face today – the encroachment of “progress” and/or development on land, water, and life. Regionally, the American West –euphemistically called the New West—as well as places in the American South (or New South) continue to struggle with uncontrolled growth, something that’s really not changed since roughly the 1950s. The reason I require the viewing of the movie, even though the book is quite a bit better, is because it places people in the land and shows a visual of how these individuals interact with their environments. Hence, I want you to think about land and life as one – what actions are being represented, or how are actions being manifested, in the landscapes. How do culture, economies, and politics play out on the land, and how do these experiences impact people? A If you’ve never really read an essay length movie review, I’ve posted a couple of examples. Your review should be no less than 750 words, and no more than 1000 words. That’s about 5 pages, with the normal fixings — double spaced, 12pt font, Times New Roman, etc. Plot: You should anticipate writing a detailed paragraph that discusses the basics of the plot and the main characters involved. Place/Landscape: Clifford Geertz) about the place and/or the landscapes that the movie takes place in, focusing on the geographical—physical and human, the regions, the movements, and the interactions—elements—i.e. what is the climate like, how is the water brought to the fields, is it urban/rural, what is grown on the land, what do the people do in the village, is their movement, etc. Analysis: film, keeping in mind the politics, economies, and cultural-environments that are being brought to light and/or are being impacted by various actors. Your analysis will be opinionated, and please show your opinions. Back your opinions up, however, with facts – this might require a bit of extra Googling – e.g. population numbers, income information, etc. (please remember to cite!). How does your analysis fit in with the experiences/environments we live, work, and play in today? West –euphemist

Answer

Introduction

“The Milagro Beanfield War,” both in its book and movie forms, is a powerful narrative set in the enchanting milieu of northern New Mexico (Widener, 2021). This essay explores why the movie adaptation is preferred over the book and delves into the profound themes it portrays – the struggle of small Hispano villages against the encroachment of progress and development on their land, water, and way of life. In an era marked by uncontrolled growth, particularly in the American West and South, this story remains as relevant as ever (Widener, 2021). The film offers a unique visual perspective that allows viewers to intimately connect with the characters and their interactions with their environment, emphasizing the inseparable relationship between land and life.

Plot Overview

“The Milagro Beanfield War,” directed by Robert Redford and based on John Nichols’ novel from the 1970s, unfolds in the fictional village of Milagro, New Mexico (Widener, 2021). The central plot revolves around Joe Mondragon, an impoverished farmer who decides to irrigate a small, abandoned beanfield, much to the dismay of a powerful local developer, Ladd Devine (Widener, 2021). As Joe’s actions defy the interests of Devine and the establishment, it sparks a conflict that exposes the tensions between traditional values and modern development in the village (Widener, 2021).

Place and Landscape

The movie’s setting is crucial to understanding its core themes. Northern New Mexico, depicted as an enchanting landscape, plays a central role in the narrative. The geographical and human elements of this region are integral to the story (Widener, 2021). The arid climate of New Mexico influences the characters’ struggles with water scarcity, while the majestic landscapes symbolize the cultural and historical significance of the land to the local Hispano community.

The film showcases the challenges faced by the villagers in bringing water to their fields, illustrating the harsh reality of agricultural life in this region. The dichotomy between urban and rural life is evident, with the village of Milagro representing a rural, close-knit community deeply rooted in its traditions. The agricultural practices, such as bean farming, and the daily routines of the people emphasize their dependence on the land (Widener, 2021).

Analysis

“The Milagro Beanfield War” provides a rich tapestry for the analysis of the interplay between politics, economies, and cultural-environments. The movie underscores the conflict between local traditions and the forces of progress and development. Ladd Devine, representing corporate interests and the new wave of development, clashes with Joe Mondragon and the villagers, who seek to preserve their way of life and connection to the land (Widener, 2021).

This conflict mirrors real-world struggles in regions like the American West and South, where uncontrolled growth has threatened the delicate balance between development and environmental sustainability (Widener, 2021). Population numbers and income disparities in these regions reveal the economic disparities that drive such conflicts, with powerful developers often exploiting vulnerable communities for profit (Widener, 2021).

The movie’s relevance extends to broader issues of land rights, environmental conservation, and cultural preservation. The experiences of the characters in Milagro resonate with contemporary challenges faced by communities worldwide (Widener, 2021). In a world grappling with climate change and the consequences of rapid urbanization, the film prompts viewers to reflect on the enduring struggle to protect the land and the values embedded within it (Widener, 2021).

Cultural Significance

One of the film’s most striking elements is its portrayal of cultural significance within the context of land and life. The Hispano community’s connection to the land in Milagro goes far beyond mere sustenance—it’s deeply intertwined with their identity and traditions (Widener, 2021). This connection is palpable throughout the movie, from the rituals associated with farming to the intimate gatherings that take place under the New Mexico sun.

Moreover, the film highlights the clash between the culture of the traditional Hispano community and the dominant culture of corporate-driven development (Widener, 2021). This cultural struggle is reflective of broader issues faced by marginalized communities worldwide. As globalization and urbanization continue to reshape societies, the preservation of cultural heritage and identity becomes a vital concern (Widener, 2021).

Environmental Concerns

“The Milagro Beanfield War” also draws attention to pressing environmental concerns. Water scarcity, a central theme in the movie, mirrors the real-world challenges faced by regions dealing with climate change and resource depletion (Widener, 2021). In Milagro, the fight over water rights underscores the urgent need for sustainable resource management.

Furthermore, the film raises questions about the environmental impact of uncontrolled development. The construction of a resort, golf course, and other amenities in the midst of a fragile ecosystem threatens not only the livelihood of the villagers but also the delicate balance of the local environment (Widener, 2021). This issue parallels contemporary debates about responsible development and the protection of natural habitats.

Economic Disparities

Economic disparities are at the heart of the conflict in “The Milagro Beanfield War.” Ladd Devine’s pursuit of profit at the expense of the villagers’ subsistence farming is emblematic of the wealth gap that plagues many societies (Widener, 2021). This disparity is further exacerbated by the loss of traditional livelihoods due to modernization and mechanization.

In today’s world, income inequality remains a significant issue, with the gap between the rich and the poor widening in many countries (Widener, 2021). “The Milagro Beanfield War” serves as a reminder of the social and economic imbalances that persist and the often-disproportionate impact they have on marginalized communities.

Relevance Today

The relevance of “The Milagro Beanfield War” in today’s world cannot be overstated. As we grapple with issues of environmental sustainability, cultural preservation, and economic inequality, the film offers valuable insights and raises critical questions (Widener, 2021). It prompts us to consider the consequences of unchecked development, the importance of cultural heritage, and the need for equitable economic systems.

The struggles faced by the characters in Milagro are emblematic of the challenges encountered by communities worldwide. From Indigenous land rights battles to protests against gentrification, these struggles persist, and “The Milagro Beanfield War” serves as a powerful reminder of the enduring fight for justice, culture, and the land (Widener, 2021).

Conclusion

“The Milagro Beanfield War,” through its cinematic adaptation, provides a poignant portrayal of the ongoing battle between progress and tradition, development and preservation, and the inseparable relationship between land and life. Its relevance endures in an era marked by uncontrolled growth and environmental concerns. By immersing viewers in the landscapes and lives of its characters, the film invites reflection on the complex interplay between culture, economy, and politics in the environments we live, work, and play in today. In this visual exploration of land and its significance, “The Milagro Beanfield War” continues to offer valuable insights into the challenges faced by communities striving to protect their way of life amidst the relentless march of progress.

Reference

Widener, Jeffrey. “The Milagro Beanfield War.” Updated January 25, 2021.

FAQ: “The Milagro Beanfield War”

What is “The Milagro Beanfield War” about?

“The Milagro Beanfield War” is a narrative, both in book and movie form, that revolves around the struggle of a small Hispano village, Milagro, against the encroachment of progress and development on their land, water, and traditional way of life. It centers on the story of Joe Mondragon, a farmer, and his conflict with a powerful local developer, Ladd Devine.

Why is the movie adaptation preferred over the book?

The movie adaptation is preferred because it provides a visual perspective that allows viewers to intimately connect with the characters and their interactions with their environment. It effectively portrays the inseparable relationship between land and life, making the themes more accessible and impactful.

What are some key themes explored in “The Milagro Beanfield War”?

The film explores several key themes, including:

• • The cultural significance of the land and its connection to the identity and traditions of the Hispano community.
  • Environmental concerns, particularly water scarcity and the impact of uncontrolled development on fragile ecosystems.
  • Economic disparities and the clash between corporate interests and traditional livelihoods.

 How does the film address cultural preservation and heritage?

“The Milagro Beanfield War” highlights the clash between the traditional culture of the Hispano community in Milagro and the dominant culture of corporate-driven development. It emphasizes the importance of preserving cultural heritage in the face of modernization.

Why is the film relevant today?

The film remains relevant in today’s world marked by rapid development, environmental challenges, and economic disparities. It serves as a reminder of the ongoing battles for justice, culture, and the land faced by communities worldwide. The themes in the film resonate with contemporary issues.