RUA: Analyzing Published Research
RUA: Analyzing Published Research
Criteria Ratings Pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeClinical Question
1. Describe the problem: What is the focus of your group’s work?
2. Significance of problem: What health outcomes result from your problem? Or what statistics document this is a problem? You may find support on websites for government or professional organizations.
3. Purpose of the paper: What will your paper do or describe?
30 pts
Highest Level of Performance
Includes 3 requirements for section.
26 pts
High Level of Performance
Includes 2 requirements for section.
24 pts
Satisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 1 requirement for section.
11 pts
Unsatisfactory Level of Performance
Present, yet includes no required criteria.
0 pts
Section not Present
No requirements for this section presented.
30 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeEvidence Matrix Table: Data Summary (Appendix A)
Categorize items in the Matrix Table, including proper intext citations and reference list entries for each article.
1. References (recent publication within the last 5 years)
2. Purpose/Hypothesis/Study Question(s)
3. Variables: Independent (I) and Dependent (D)
4. Study Design
5. Sample Size and Selection
6. Data Collection Methods
7. Major Findings (Evidence)
60 pts
Highest Level of Performance
Includes 7 requirements for section.
56 pts
High Level of Performance
Includes 6 requirements for section.
47 pts
Satisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 5 requirements for section.
25 pts
Unsatisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 4 or less requirements for section.
0 pts
Section not Present
No requirements for this section presented.
60 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeDescriiption of Findings
Describe the data in the Matrix Table, including proper intext citations and reference list entries for each article.
1. Compare and contrast variables within each study.
2. What are the study design and procedures used in each study; qualitative, quantitative, or mixed method study, levels of confidence in each study, etc.?
3. Participant demographics and information.
4. Instruments used, including reliability and validity.
5. How do the research findings provide evidence to support your clinical problem, or what further evidence is needed to answer your question?
6. Next steps: Identify two questions that can help guide the group’s
60 pts
Highest Level of Performance
Includes 6 requirements for section.
53 pts
High Level of Performance
Includes 5 requirements for section.
47 pts
Satisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 4 requirements for section.
23 pts
Unsatisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 3 or less requirements for section.
0 pts
Section not Present
No requirements for this section presented.
60 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeConclusion
1. Review major findings in a summary paragraph.
2. Evidence to address your clinical problem.
3. Make a connection back to all the included sections.
4. Wrap up the assignment and give the reader something to think about.
20 pts
Highest Level of Performance
Includes 3 requirements for section.
18 pts
High Level of Performance
Includes 2 requirements for section.
15 pts
Satisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 1 requirement for section.
8 pts
Unsatisfactory Level of Performance
Present, yet includes no required criteria.
0 pts
Section not Present
No requirements for this section presented.
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeFormat
1. Correct grammar and spelling
2. Include a title and reference page
3. Use of headings for each section:
– Problem
– Synthesis of the Literature
*Variables
*Methods
*Participants
*Instruments
*Implications for Future Work
4. Conclusion
5. Adheres to current APA formatting and guidelines
6. Includes at least two (2) scholarly, current (within 5 years) primary sources other than the textbook
7. 3-4 pages in length excluding appendices, title, and reference pages
30 pts
Highest Level of Performance
Includes 7 requirements for section.
26 pts
High Level of Performance
Includes 6 requirements for section.
23 pts
Satisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 5 requirements for section.
11 pts
Unsatisfactory Level of Performance
Includes 4 or less requirements for section.
0 pts
Section not Present
No requirements for this section presented.
30 pts
Total Points: 200
