The Role of Environmental Scanning in Community Research

Introduction

Community research plays a pivotal role in understanding the needs, challenges, and opportunities within a specific geographical area or community. One of the key tools employed in community research is the environmental scan, which enables researchers to gather vital information about the external factors influencing a community. This essay aims to describe the role of the environmental scan as a tool for community research, elucidate its utility, and explore related concepts such as trends, competition, technology, service providers, economy, labor supply, and the political/legislative arena in the context of a capstone project’s environment. Additionally, the essay will examine how the chosen topic of interest connects to existing or evolving legislation or policies and how this can affect community research or the presentation of research. Finally, it will propose changes in current practices and justify why advocating for these changes is essential.

Role of the Environmental Scan in Community Research

An environmental scan, also known as an environmental assessment, is a systematic process of gathering, analyzing, and interpreting information from the external environment to identify opportunities and threats that may impact an organization or community (Kondrak, 2016). In the context of community research, the environmental scan plays a multifaceted role:

1. Data Collection: The scan serves as the primary means of collecting data about the external environment of a community. This includes demographic data, economic indicators, social trends, and more. For instance, in a capstone project focused on a specific neighborhood, an environmental scan would gather data on the neighborhood’s population, income levels, educational attainment, and crime rates.
2. Understanding Trends: It helps in understanding prevailing and emerging trends that can shape the community’s future. This is crucial for developing effective strategies and interventions. For instance, if the environmental scan reveals a rising trend in the use of technology for healthcare delivery, this could inform the development of telemedicine services in the community.
3. Identifying Stakeholders: The scan helps in identifying key stakeholders in the community. These stakeholders may include local government agencies, non-profit organizations, businesses, and community leaders. Understanding who the stakeholders are is essential for collaboration and resource mobilization.
4. Assessing Resources: It aids in assessing the availability of resources within the community. This includes identifying available healthcare facilities, educational institutions, and community centers. Such information is vital for planning and allocating resources effectively.
5. Assessing Risks and Opportunities: By examining factors such as economic conditions, political stability, and market competition, the environmental scan helps identify potential risks and opportunities. For instance, if there is a decline in the local economy, this could pose challenges for community development projects, and strategies may need to be adjusted accordingly.
6. Policy Analysis: Environmental scanning can reveal the impact of existing policies and legislation on the community. This is particularly relevant when researching topics with policy implications, as it helps in understanding how policies are affecting the community and whether they are achieving their intended outcomes.

Utility of the Environmental Scan in Community Research

The utility of the environmental scan in community research is evident in its ability to provide a comprehensive understanding of the external factors that influence a community. Here are some key aspects of its utility:

Informed Decision-Making

An environmental scan equips researchers, policymakers, and community leaders with data-driven insights. This information allows them to make informed decisions about resource allocation, program development, and policy formulation. For example, if the scan reveals a growing aging population in the community, decision-makers may prioritize the establishment of senior care services.

Strategic Planning

Community research often serves as the foundation for strategic planning. The data obtained from an environmental scan assists in setting clear goals, objectives, and action plans. It helps communities allocate resources efficiently and prioritize areas that require immediate attention.

Collaboration and Partnership Building

Understanding the external environment through environmental scanning facilitates collaboration and partnership building. When stakeholders have a clear picture of the community’s strengths and weaknesses, they can work together to address its needs. For example, a scan may reveal a shortage of affordable housing, prompting collaboration between local government and nonprofit organizations to address this issue.

Monitoring and Evaluation

An environmental scan is not a one-time activity; it is an ongoing process. Communities can use it for continuous monitoring and evaluation of their progress. By periodically conducting scans, they can track changes in the external environment and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Risk Mitigation

Identifying potential risks through environmental scanning allows communities to take proactive measures to mitigate them. For instance, if the scan identifies environmental factors that increase the risk of natural disasters, the community can invest in disaster preparedness and resilience measures.

Community Empowerment

The process of conducting an environmental scan often involves community engagement and participation. This empowers community members to take an active role in identifying their needs and contributing to solutions. In this way, the scan can promote community ownership and empowerment.

Advocacy

Data obtained from environmental scanning can be a powerful tool for advocacy. When communities have evidence-based information about their challenges, they can advocate for policy changes and resource allocation at the local, state, or national level. For instance, if the scan reveals disparities in access to healthcare, community advocates can use this data to push for improved healthcare services.

Environmental Scanning Concepts in the Capstone Project’s Environment

In the context of a capstone project, it is essential to apply environmental scanning concepts to gain insights into the specific environment being studied. Let’s explore how several key concepts from environmental scanning relate to a hypothetical capstone project focused on healthcare access in an underserved urban community.

Trends

Trends are critical in understanding the trajectory of a community. In the healthcare access capstone project, trends might include the increasing use of telemedicine, a growing demand for mental health services, or a shift towards value-based care. These trends can inform the development of healthcare programs and services tailored to the community’s evolving needs.

Competition

Competition in healthcare can impact access and quality of care. Identifying competing healthcare providers and services in the urban community is vital. The capstone project might explore how competition affects healthcare affordability and availability, and whether it drives innovation or creates barriers for vulnerable populations.

Technology

Technology plays a transformative role in healthcare. Examining the technology landscape within the community can reveal opportunities for improving healthcare access. For instance, assessing the community’s digital infrastructure and access to smartphones can inform strategies for implementing telehealth solutions to reach underserved residents.

Service Providers

Identifying existing healthcare service providers and their capacity is crucial. Are there sufficient primary care providers, clinics, and specialists to meet the community’s healthcare needs? The capstone project may involve mapping healthcare facilities and assessing their capacity to serve the population.

Economy

Economic conditions within the community directly impact healthcare access. High unemployment rates or low-income levels can result in financial barriers to healthcare. The capstone project could analyze how economic factors affect healthcare utilization and propose interventions to address financial disparities in access.

Labor Supply

The availability of healthcare professionals is a key consideration. Is there a shortage of healthcare workers in the community, particularly in underserved specialties? The capstone project may explore strategies for recruiting and retaining healthcare professionals to improve access.

Political/Legislative Arena

The political and legislative environment can shape healthcare policies and funding. The capstone project might assess how existing policies impact healthcare access in the community. For example, are there Medicaid expansion opportunities that could improve coverage for low-income residents?

Connection to Legislation and Policies

In the hypothetical capstone project focused on healthcare access, it is imperative to connect the chosen topic to existing or evolving legislation and policies. In this case, healthcare access is closely tied to a range of healthcare policies at the federal, state, and local levels. Some key connections include:

1. Affordable Care Act (ACA): The ACA has had a significant impact on healthcare access in the United States. The capstone project could examine how the ACA has affected access to insurance coverage in the community and whether Medicaid expansion, a component of the ACA, could improve access further.
2. Medicaid Policies: State-level Medicaid policies vary, and they can influence eligibility criteria and coverage options. The project may investigate how state-specific Medicaid policies impact access to care for low-income residents in the chosen community.
3. Telehealth Legislation: Telehealth policies have evolved, especially in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The capstone project could assess how changes in telehealth regulations have affected access to remote healthcare services in the urban community.
4. Community Health Centers: Federal funding supports community health centers that serve underserved populations. The project may explore the role of these centers in improving healthcare access and whether legislative changes could enhance their services.
5. Local Health Initiatives: At the local level, there may be initiatives and policies related to public health and healthcare access. Analyzing these local policies can provide insights into community-specific solutions.

Advocating for Change

Based on the findings of the capstone project, it may be necessary to advocate for changes in current practices to improve healthcare access in the urban community. Advocacy for change should be guided by evidence and a commitment to addressing disparities in healthcare access. Here are some potential changes worth advocating for:

1. Expansion of Medicaid: If the research demonstrates that many residents in the community are uninsured due to income limitations, advocating for the expansion of Medicaid eligibility could extend coverage to more individuals and families.
2. Telehealth Expansion: If telehealth is shown to be an effective means of increasing healthcare access, advocating for permanent telehealth expansion and reimbursement policies can ensure continued access to virtual care services.
3. Community Health Worker Programs: If there’s a shortage of healthcare professionals, advocating for the creation and funding of community health worker programs can bridge the gap by providing essential healthcare services and education to residents.
4. Enhanced Funding for Community Health Centers: Advocating for increased federal and state funding for community health centers serving underserved populations can improve access to primary care and preventive services.
5. Addressing Social Determinants of Health: If the research reveals that social determinants of health, such as housing and food insecurity, are major barriers to healthcare access, advocacy efforts can focus on policies and programs that address these social factors.
6. Health Equity Initiatives: Advocacy should prioritize initiatives aimed at achieving health equity. This may involve policy changes that specifically target reducing healthcare disparities in marginalized communities.
7. Community Education: Promoting health literacy and community education initiatives can empower residents to navigate the healthcare system more effectively. Advocating for funding for such programs can have a long-term impact on access.
8. Collaboration and Partnerships: Advocacy efforts can also involve promoting collaboration between healthcare providers, community organizations, and local government agencies to develop holistic solutions to healthcare access challenges.

In advocating for these changes, it is crucial to engage with policymakers, community leaders, and stakeholders. Evidence from the capstone project, combined with community input, can strengthen the case for policy reforms and resource allocation to improve healthcare access.

Conclusion

The environmental scan is an invaluable tool in community research, providing a systematic approach to collecting and analyzing data about the external environment. Its utility lies in informing decision-making, facilitating strategic planning, enabling collaboration, and promoting community empowerment. When applied to a capstone project, environmental scanning concepts such as trends, competition, technology, service providers, economy, labor supply, and the political/legislative arena offer insights into the specific environment being studied. Moreover, connecting the research topic to existing legislation and policies can shed light on how policies impact the community and guide advocacy efforts for change. Ultimately, advocating for change in current practices, guided by evidence and a commitment to equity, is essential for improving the well-being of communities and addressing disparities in access to essential services like healthcare.

References

Arrington, E. (2019). Field research. In Salem Press Encyclopedia. Salem Press.

Foster, R. (2013, July 10). How to interview subject matter experts for your white papers and other B2B marketing content. Fresh Perspective.

Kondrak, C. L. (2016). Environmental scanning: A strategic perspective. In Leadership 2030 (pp. 1-23). Springer.

Shepard, B. (2015). Learning from community projects. In Community projects as social activism: From direct action to direct services (pp. 24–32). SAGE Publications, Inc.

Shepard, B. (2015). Research as action. In Community projects as social activism: From direct action to direct services (pp. 48–57). SAGE Publications, Inc.

Walden University, LLC. (2021). What is an environmental scan? [Video]. Walden University Canvas.