Option #1: Portfolio Project: Restorative Justice Applications
Compare and contrast, within a chosen subset of criminal justice, the traditional criminal justice response to crime with a restorative response to similar crimes.
Choose a subset of criminal justice in the United States, including, but not limited to: juvenile justice; criminal or discipline issues in institutions of higher education; parole, probation, or other areas of corrections; gendered violence response; or other crimes of severe violence.
Within your chosen subset, research the traditional retributive response to crime. Present the typical processes and consequences that an offender may experience through the mainstream criminal justice system. Also, detail the roles that the victim and community play in these proceedings. You may use your pre-existing knowledge of or experience with the criminal justice system to inform your account, or you may locate an actual case study or published account and draw from that for your project.
Research ways in which communities are applying restorative responses in similar cases occurring in the area you have chosen. Find at least two specific cases of restorative responses in the literature and describe the methods used to address harm. Provide a detailed account of each of these responses. Detail the role and importance of the offender, victim, and community in the process. If you have personal knowledge of a specific restorative program, you may substitute that for one of the restorative response accounts.
After presenting the retributive justice response to a crime and fully exploring at least two restorative justice responses to similar incidents, draw your own conclusions regarding the end results for each example. Consider some of the following points in your evaluation:
Zehr’s current position that western justice systems and restorative processes are not in competition, but can work in concert with each other
The importance of protecting civil rights in western justice systems and how these protections fit into a restorative process
The importance of community safety, and the ability of restorative processes to attend to the safety of victims and communities
Issues involving disparity of responses affecting communities of color
The wide array of outcomes that are possible when communities exert ultimate control over responses to wrong-doing, without any standardization that currently exists in our court system
Discuss how restorative justice might grow or change in the future for the area you are researching. How do you see that particular area changing in the future with regard to how criminal behavior is addressed? Given what you have learned through your research, what role do you think restorative justice should or will play in the criminal justice system?
In closing, present your ideas about the ways in which restorative justice will impact the justice system as a whole.
Preliminary Deliverables
