“We have discussed whether or not art and value are real. Art and value are both words that I think everybody thinks everybody else understands, or at least mostly, when we use them, and I think there is fairly limited evidence that very many people’s definition of those words are the same. They might be close, but frequently are very different. So, this paper is basically what does real mean? What is your personal definition of real? What is your general definition of real? To what extent do those definitions interrelate? To what extent do they need to? ” – Professor’s prompt