• Sketch out the arguments for and against Hobby Lobby Inc. In your view, what are the strongest arguments that support the company’s position? Do you agree with Hobby Lobby’s contention of “complicity” if it provided the abortifacient contraceptives to its employees as part of its insurance package?
• Do you agree with the reasoning behind the Supreme Court’s decision? If not, do you agree with the elements of Justice Ginsburg’s dissenting opinion which were presented in the case?
• Should for-profit (but closely held) corporations like Hobby Lobby have a right to the free exercise of religion as guaranteed under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution? Do you worry about the negative implications of recognizing such a right?
